Tolerance


There is a lot of talk about tolerance and respect.  Both are essential in creating community. What does tolerance mean with regard to holding onto our own convictions?  In his book Crisis, Covenant and Creativity, Rabbi Dr. Nathan Lopes Cardozo writes:

Let us be clear about one thing: apathy has nothing to do with tolerance.  We cannot achieve tolerance by relinquishing our every conviction. Tolerance, rather, speaks of the case in which we have convictions, but nonetheless are able to tolerate those with conviction different from our own.  In fact, the stronger our convictions, the more opportunity we have to be tolerant when faced by those with whom we disagree. But if we just don’t believe in anything, what is there to be tolerant about? (37-38)

This is where respect plays a major role.  How we speak with and about people with whom we disagree speaks volumes about who we are and how we create community.  We do not have to like everything or anything another community member says or believes, but we do need to try and understand it.  There is a difference between liking something and understanding it. I believe a mensch is someone who disagrees with a person but can still see the legitimacy in a piece of their opinion or argument.  

 

9.13.18


The ten days between Rosh haShanna and Yom Kippur are referred to as the Ten days of Repentance. They are a time for us to reflect on the past year and an opportunity to think about how we would like to grow in the upcoming year. I hope this passage from Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo’s book, Crisis, Covenant and Creativity is gives you some guidance in this pursuit.

Man’s heart is drawn after his actions.  What he does will ultimately be what he is.  In the realm of spiritual growth, action takes precedence because it alone is the medium of personal transformation.  But not all actions produce the same effect. Halacha is the musical score that molds our actions into a symphony of the divine.  We may start by borrowing notes that perhaps we would not ourselves have written, but when we play them, with compassion, the sounds they make will soon resonate within us.  And at the moment when we start to hear the music of our own souls issue forth, there can be no doubt that its Composer was also our Creator. (pg.34)

9.6.18


“Jewish continuity and survival depends upon Jews recognizing that their identities spring from thousands of years of carrying out a divine mission.  Neither the Holocaust nor the State of Israel will provide them with a solid identity. If we want to survive, and if we believe that it matters whether or not there are Jews in the world, then we must look back into our traditions, re-evaluate them and come to understand ourselves as essentially Jewish selves” (Crisis, Covenant and Creativity,102, Rabbi Dr. Nathan Lopes Cardozo).
This quote comes from one of my favorite Jewish thinkers.  Rabbi Cardozo heads a Think Tank focused on finding new Halachic and philosophical approaches to dealing with the crisis of religion and identity amongst Jews and the Jewish State of Israel. Rabbi Cardozo is known for his original and often controversial insights into Judaism. I will be bringing some of his thoughts to you over the year.  I hope you find them insightful and I hope they provide you with an opportunity to think about your Judaism in a novel way.
I welcome the opportunity to discuss this quote or anything else with you. Please stop by or email me at mfaudem@gmail.com.

4.23.18


“Love your fellow man as yourself, I am the Almighty” (Leviticus 19:18).  The Talmud (Shabbat 31a) relates that a non-Jew came to Hillel and said to him, “Convert me on condition that you will teach me the entire Torah while I stand on one foot.”  Hillel accepted the condition and told him, “What you dislike, do not do to your friend. This is the entire Torah.” Since Hillel was referring to the commandment of love your neighbor, why didn’t he just mention the words in this verse?  

Rabbi Yeruchem Levoitz explained that this is to teach us an important principle.  From the words “love your fellow man” one might think that as long as one feels the emotion of love towards others, one fulfills the commandment.  But the truth is that just feeling love alone is not sufficient. Rather this love must motivate us to do positive things for others and to refrain from any actions or words that could cause someone any pain or suffering.  The Torah definitely requires us to feel deep love for others in our hearts. But even more than that, our behavior towards others must manifest this love. Therefore, Hillel explained to this man that a basic Torah principle is that the same commandment which requires us to have a profoundly positive feeling for others, also requires us to behave in an elevated manner in our daily encounters with them (Daat Torah: Vayikra, p. 175).  Constantly be on the lookout for acts of kindness you can do for other people.  When you look for them, you will constantly find things to do and words to say. Similarly, be very careful not to do anything that will harm others or cause them any pain or suffering.  This is a lifelong challenge, and it is a cornerstone of the Torah.

4.16.18


Moses and Aaron are instructed regarding the diagnosis of tzaraat, which is usually translated as leprosy.  It is an ailment, which has the ability of affecting human skin, clothing.  If infected, the human being or garment is declared ritually impure. Rashes, patches and discolorations of the affected individual or object are examined by a priest who determines the existence of the affliction.  

God instructs Moshe in the purification process for a leper who has been declared clean.  Two clean birds are to be brought to the priest. One is sacrificed, and the other bird is set free.  After a week, the person to be purified shave all of their hair and immerse in water. They then bring a guilt offering and a sin offering.

Rashi offers a rationale for the two birds.  Since tzaraat comes in retribution for lashon hara, which is, in effect, babbling words, the Torah requires for the metzora’s purification birds which babble and twitter continually.  But why two birds? Wouldn’t one have served the purpose? And why was one bird slaughtered and the other kept alive to be sent away “towards the fields”?  The power of speech is a double-edged sword.

When used properly it is a beneficial instrument for studying, teaching and creating community and meaning. Used improperly, in the form of slander and lying, speech can be deadly.  Our Sages explain that the sacrifices are designed to make the donor mindful of the fact that the sacrificed animal is taking his place, in reality he deserved to suffer the fate of the sacrifice.  Had there been only the slaughtered bird, the metzora would then have inferred that all forms of speech are evil and deadly.  He may not have uttered another word for the rest of his life. The live bird that is sent away toward the fields shows him that the power of speech can be a source of life and strength.  Indeed, the pair of birds epitomizes the saying that “Death and life are in the power of the tongue” (Mishlei 18:21). (Shlomo Ganzfried, author of the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch)

4.9.18


Parashat Shemini begins on the last day of the ordination ceremony of Aaron and his sons as priests. Aaron’s sons, Nadav and Avihu, offer an alien fire to God . A fire comes from God, and both sons die immediately. Moses tells Aaron that the deaths of Nadav and Avihu demonstrate the responsibility of priests to do only what God has specifically commanded them. Moses calls on Aaron’s nephews to remove the bodies, and cautions relatives and the rest of the congregation not to mourn the deaths.

God commands Aaron and his sons not to drink intoxicants when they enter the Tent of Meeting, for them to be able to carry out their duties. God speaks to Moses and Aaron regarding the laws of kashrut. They are told that the Israelites are permitted to eat any mammal which has both a split hooves and chews its cud. The Israelites are permitted to eat any fish which has both fins and scales. A list of forbidden birds is given. Four-legged insects are forbidden unless they have a pair of jointed legs with which they can leap. The parasha ends with an affirmation of the special relationship between God and the people of Israel.

Some commentators explain that out of their joy of serving God, Nadav and Avihu brought an additional sacrifice.  If this were so, death seems an extreme, and even unjust, punishment. Hertz explains that they were punished according to their elevated status and that this was a warning to future priestly generations not to innovate their own sacrifices.

Passover.18


The Background to the Passover Holiday from Teaching Jewish Holidays:

Leviticus 23:5-8 contains the biblical injunctions to celebrate the festival of Pesach: “in the first month, on the fourteenth day of the month, as twilight, there shall be a passover offering to the Lord, and on the fifteenth day of the month is the Lord’s Feast of Unleavened Bread.  You shall eat unleavened for seven days. The first day shall be for you a sacred occasion: you shall not work at your occupations. Seven days you shall make offerings by fire to Adonai. The seventh day shall be a sacred occasion: you shall not work at your occupations.”

Efforts to probe the origins of the Jewish holidays are in no way intended to denigrate the importance or the meaning of the festivals. Rather, they help to demonstrate the genius of the Jewish people who drew from their environment, transforming what might have begun as a pagan idea or practice into something with universal and timeless significance.

According to such scholars as Hayyim Schauss and Theodor Gaster, the modern festival of Pesach is a combination of a shepherd’s festival and an agricultural festival.  Leviticus 23 reinforces this idea.

It is possible that a Pesach festival had its earliest stirrings among semi-nomads who thousands of years ago wandered the desert and the semi-arid environs around Palestine.  Nisan was the month when sheep most often gave birth. These nomads came to observe a festival at the time of the full moon. Just before nightfall, a sheep or goat was sacrificed. The animal was then roasted, and the family ate a hasty meal so that all of the animal would be eaten before daybreak.  No bones of this sacrificial animal could be broken. Tent posts were daubed with the blood of the slain animal as an antidote to plagues, misfortune, and illness.

Perhaps the Feast of Unleavened Bread was a six or seven day festival marking the beginning of the spring harvest and the offering of the first sheaf of the newly cut barley to the priest as a sacrifice to God.  The elimination of chametz may have originally been precautionary so as not to infect the new incoming crop.  Or, it may have been a way of propitiating the priests and God so as to assume health and bounty.

As Judaism moved away from being agriculturally based, new interpretations and new customs were added to the Pesach ritual so that Jews living all over the world and in all ages could meaningfully celebrate Pesach.  The prototype Haggadah finds its way into the Mishnah as Tractate Pesachim.  By the end of the Talmudic period, its form and much of its content were as they are today.  It must have been widely accepted, because the Haggadah was included in the very first prayer book of Rav Amram in the eighth century, as well as in the prayer book of Saadia Gaon in Babylonia (tenth century).  Somewhere around the twelfth century, it began to be copied as a separate book. It attracted many commentaries, and became the favorite subject of Jewish artists who found the subject liberating.

3.19.18


Parashat Tzav begins by repeating the procedure for the sacrifices discussed in last week’s Parasha.  This time the Torah directs its words to Aaron and his sons, giving details regarding the portions of the sacrifices they receive.  

God commands Moses to prepare Aaron, his sons, and the Tabernacle for the priesthood.  This includes washing Aaron and his sons, dressing them in their ritual garments, and anointing both Aaron and the Tabernacle with oil. Moses explains that this ceremony will last seven days, and all that has been done and sacrificed that day has to be repeated on each of the following days.

The book Teaching Torah gives a beautiful insight into the role of the priests and the priestly offering.  The priests, especially the High Priest, were role models for the Israelites. The High Priest had to be sinless in order to carry out his duties.  But, since no individual is sinless, the High Priest brought a daily sacrifice atoning for any sins he may have committed.

So what do we learn from this?  If the High Priest can bring a sacrifice, admitting that he needed to repent for any sins and asking for forgiveness, his action may motivate others to do so as well.  The High Priest brought and offered his sacrifices publicly, without feeling ashamed. This was a message to the Israelites that they also should bringing sacrifices of atonement and not feel ashamed for their need for repentance.

Judaism is not a religion which demands perfection.  Its creators knew that human beings were not perfect people and could never be perfect people.  Therefore, it sets up rituals and prayers that respond to the realistic nature, both positive and negative, of daily human life.  

Judaism is a religion that demands continuous growth and development of the human being.  The observances of Mitzvot are the vehicle through which we as Jews develop and grow intellectually, spiritually, and ritually.  Whether it is lighting Shabbat candles, giving Tzedakah, or observing Kashrut, all are important and all should be viewed as the stepping stone to the next level of knowledge and observance.

 

3.12.18


With this week’s Torah portion, we begin reading the book of Leviticus.  Parashat VaYikra opens with God instructing Moses to describe the five types of sacrifices to the Israelites.  They were: a burnt offering (olah); the meal offering (minchah); the sacrifice of wellbeing (zevach shelamim); the sin offering (chatat); and the guilt offering (asham).

While the first three types of sacrifices were voluntary and not brought for atonement, the last two sacrifices, the chatat and the asham were both obligatory for guilty parties.  The offering to be brought was determined by the economic status of the person who committed the transgression.  The penalty for robbery was also to restore the stolen item, plus an additional one-fifth of its value.

The bringing of sacrifices did not, in and of itself, appease God for one’s wrongdoing; rather it served merely as a symbol and expression of one’s desire to repent and, in that, to change one’s behavior. The essential element in repentance is the attitude of the individual.  With the destruction of the Temple, the sacrifices were discontinued. The Sages then prescribed other practices to substitute for the sacrifices. The most important were prayer, Torah study, and tzedakah. Just as prayer, study, and tzedakah require whole-hearted commitment and discipline, so repentance requires a whole-hearted commitment to change one’s ways.

3.5.18


In this week’s Torah portion, Moses assembles the Israelites and reminds them of the commandment to observe Shabbat as a day of rest.  He also instructs them not to kindle light on Shabbat. Moses then reviews God’s instructions concerning the building of the Tabernacle and calls upon the people to bring gifts to be used in its construction. When Moses sees that the work is complete, he blesses the people of Israel.  Then God tells Moses to erect the Tabernacle on the first day of the first month and to place in it all of its specially crafted furnishings.  Moses then anoints Aaron and his four sons to be priests as God commanded him.

When Moses has finished the work, the cloud of God covers the Tabernacle and the presence of God fills it.  When the cloud is lifted from the Tabernacle, it is a signal to the Israelites to break camp and begin travel.  Throughout the journeys of the Israelites, a cloud of the Lord is present by day and a fire by night.

The placement of the prohibition of work on Shabbat immediately before the description of the building of the Tabernacle led the Rabbis to understand “work” – “milacha” to mean any activity that was needed for the construction of the Tabernacle.  The Mishnah (Shabbat 7:2) lists thirty-nine main categories of work – “avot” and there are many other kinds of work which are outgrowths of these main thirty-nine that are also forbidden. These latter are called toledot – offspring.  For example: sowing is in the avot category, therefore, watering plants is considered in the toledot class.